Brief History of the Theophiliacs
January 8, 2010
On account of our being linked by two excellent sites recently, Clavi Non De Fixi and Covenant, our traffic has gone up significantly. So also has the traffic into our archives. Considering the large assortment of writers and positions we have had since the blog’s inception I thought, in order to clear up any confusion, I would compose a very brief intro to the blog.
“The Theophiliacs” started as a casual group of mostly disgruntled students from North Central University in Minneapolis. At first we gathered at an historic Twin Cities saloon to smoke our barely seasoned Briar pipes and sip the local libations.
This initial group consisted of an assortment of people but those who would go on to start this blog were Daniel Shoemake, Jeremy Girhenah, Reed Carlson and Tony Hunt. All of us had been raised mostly Assemblies of God and both Reed and Tony are sons of A/G pastors.
Even at this early stage we had begun to grow into our respective theological horizons, even if still as infants. Jeremy had increasingly become agnostic in regards to whether or not we can know anything about god or whether god was identifiably like the one he had long believed in. He became an advocate for radical religous pluralism and is still hoping to study Islam and other faiths. Ironically he is still the only original member to be attending an Assemblies of God church!
Daniel was becoming more ‘progressive.’ He is active in The Episcopal Church and Integrity. He hopes to study at the famous Tubingen school in Germany and to possibly pursue ordination in The Episcopal Church.
But back to the narrative.
Eventually the group shrunk and moved to Tony’s house for fires, beers, and more smoking in the backyard. We found that we enjoyed more ‘focused’ conversations and in time Tony “presented” a paper for discussion (be merciful, it was like my first such paper). It was this that sparked interest in the idea of a blog where we could propose various topics, each write on it and play off each others ideas.
Our initial energies focused around religous authority, pluralism, homosexuality and how to speak of God. In the meantime we picked up a couple readers and added Anthony D. Jacques as a contributer. (Some of his posts will have the Name-as-Image thing we do and others will simply have “Anthony” at the bottom. All of Tony Hunt’s should say “adhunt” at the bottom and/or have an “Anthony Dale Hunt” image at the head of the post.) He too had been raised Pentecostal. He is a gifted writer and was incredibly vulnerable with his spiritual struggles and journey, especially as it related to his suffering through Lukemia. Anthony quickly came to be unable to maintain interest in writing about the things we were writing about and so he started his own blog. (unfortunately both him and his blog have been hounded and harrased by fundamentalists and his blog has become largely inactive, though he has begun a new one dedicated mostly to his creative writing where our site is sadly absent from mention)
But, having discussed to the point of exhaustion certain themes, and with more school, more children, the buying of houses and the beginning of grad school, the core group of Theophiliacs in MN has lost it’s ability to meet regularly and to discuss with focus. Reed, Dan, Jeremy and Tony still get together but it is more casual and ad hoc.
And so the blog began to shift. Anthony, Jeremy and Dan in turn opted out of active composition for the blog, thus the wide theological diversity and “lively” disagreement has largely been left behind.
But we received a new direction and fresh breath from a place very much the opposite of Minnesota, New Mexico.
James Stambaugh and Shawn Wamsely had been long time readers and Reed and I began to pester them to become contributers. James too had attended North Central University and was a writer for the school paper which is how Reed knew him. Shawn is James’ brother-in-law and is, as the “About Us” page indicates, is the “old man” of the group. He is also the most thoroughly educated and has the luxury of being able to post old Master’s-level papers as multi-part blog posts.
Both of them had become Episcopalian as well and so our new energies often play around with Anglican history, theology, liturgy and news. That is absolutely not our sole focus – I’m due for another Beer post soon – but it has given us a sort of “center.” Four pentecostals turned Anglicans largely representing the “Center,” some a bit left, some a bit right; all determined to not become a bitching and exclusionary site. From here you can pick it up by reading our “About Us” page. It seems the future of the blog is anything but certain!

January 9, 2010 at 4:24
Superbly written — fantastic introduction. Thanks !
January 9, 2010 at 8:59
Thanks. I think I said the word “focus” too much. Really I just threw it together but I hope it helps out.
January 9, 2010 at 16:07
Keep up the good work.
January 9, 2010 at 16:17
You’re fun and random. Keep it up!
January 10, 2010 at 11:11
Interesting stuff, Tony. Thanks.
January 10, 2010 at 17:30
we used to be white western male protestants discussing religion but no we’re…uh…uh…
The more things change, eh? This is one of the most fun blogs I’ve been on in a while. I like what you guys have to say and appreciate the seeds of friendship. Peace.
January 11, 2010 at 12:32
Tony,
Good post – I don’t think there is any way that we can know how long this will continue. However, I have certainly been encouraged, educated, and motivated by the relationships on this blog.
It would be fun to see it continue through doctoral work, ordinations, etc., because (as you have pointed out with your own material) it is largely embarrassing to go back to your old work. However, it is also hugely important in seeing how far the work of the Spirit has moved us.
Peace
January 13, 2010 at 13:23
As a late-comer, thanks for the history. And thanks for the link to clavi non defixi as well.
January 18, 2010 at 17:13
Oh, I didn’t realize you guys were still reading.
Blogroll ammended and 50 hail mary’s recited.
January 18, 2010 at 17:18
PS. And I still check in on you guys every once in a while. I wish I had something to add now and again, but alas, I usually have no idea what you guys are talking about.
Glad to see you’re moving in a positive new direction, regardless.
January 19, 2010 at 15:45
Good to see ya’ round Tony. Make it 55 hail mary’s and I’ll be happy.
January 19, 2010 at 16:59
Consider it done.
January 20, 2010 at 12:18
ADJ’s back!
April 22, 2010 at 22:27
Wow, just tripped over you guys trying to find a quote out there. I think it was by CS Lewis (?). He was referring to someone else giving up cigars or pipes and said that it was his last trace of humanity…. Seriously, could my suggestion get any more vague? Hehe… sorry bout that but its been floating in my head and I really want to identify it.
GREAT SITE though, if it wasn’t so late, I would stay longer and read more.. definitely going to book mark it..
Nice to find you all out there!
May 18, 2011 at 23:45
This is absolutely insane.
I am a son of an A/G pastor who grew up to major in Theology and Psychology at Evangel University (the A/G flagship) who went on to deny the AG and join an Episcopal church because of my stance on homosexuality (I’m gay) along with other issues I had with the AG doctrine AND I fully enjoy beer and smoking pipes… almost more than I love studying World Religions, which was my minor.
What are the odds that we are somehow related?!?
May 19, 2011 at 8:53
Forrest,
Welcome! What do you do now (other than smoke pipes, drink beer, and attend the Episcopal Church)? Are you still a student, career?
May 19, 2011 at 9:29
I am currently getting my graduate degree in counseling psychology with an emphasis in the psychology of religion.
I like long walks on the beach, sipping hot cocoa by the fireplace, and debating on the nature of Plato’s dialogues.
May 19, 2011 at 9:39
Oh yea, I am also a 32nd degree Freemason and a “Knight Templar” Freemason. If that means anything at all to you. LOL
May 19, 2011 at 9:45
Hmmm, you may actually be right – we might have all been separated at birth. :0)
May 19, 2011 at 12:26
Well howdy, Forrest! It’s always fun to find a fellow traveler. You’d be surprised by how many emails we get saying they’ve had very similar roads. Something there is in a pentecostal that loves the charismatic force of the liturgy. Have a good one.