Flux II: Why Old Stuff Matters
May 29, 2009

“Flux” is a continuing series on my year visiting churches of various Christian traditions.
|
I first experienced Eastern Orthodoxy as a 21-year-old traveling through Ukraine. Even then, the tradition enchanted me. At the time I was interning with a missions organization working in Eastern Europe. I knew that many of the churches we were helping to plant were located in heavily Eastern Orthodox or Roman Catholic areas. It was also become increasingly clear that these traditions were undoubtedly Christian, perhaps in some ways even more Christian than me. So why are we evangelizing Christians? I wondered.
It was the opening spark of a lesson that took me a few years to learn: old stuff matters.
By “old stuff,” I mean the bulk of the ancient practices and symbols many modern Evangelicals (both intentionally and unintentionally) learned to de-emphasize or ignore. In my studies, I realized there were a number of questions I’d never fully explored: where did the Bible come from? who first outlined concepts like the dual-natures of Christ and the Trinity? what is our modern conception of hell based on? Many of the answers to these questions were found in studying the first few centuries of Christianity, an area of scholarship sometimes called Patristics or a little more broadly, Christian Origins.
I learned that whether one recited the creeds in church or not, they were formative and part of our shared Christian heritage. Whether one appreciated liturgy or found it dull, it was influential in shaping modern forms of worship. I learned that Sacramental theology left a precedent for how we expected to experience God–even if one didn’t look for Him in Eucharist anymore. Most importantly I learned that issues like church governance, division, authority, human sexuality and the role of the Church in the world were problems as old as Pentecost.
Perhaps most poignantly, however, I was struck by how bewitching the tradional forms of worship could be. The ancient liturgies enchanted me, the Icons arrested me–I felt myself being pulled into something older and bigger and altogether more enveloping than my previous, more individualistic Church experiences had been. All my life, I had endeavored to maintain the right belief or “Apostolicity*” of my faith. But it wasn’t until my year of visiting Churches, that I was first introduced to its commanility or “Catholicity**.”
* (Apostolicity in this case, just means the faith of Apostles, or what was handed down to us.)
** (Catholic not in the Roman sense, but in it’s older meaning of ‘universal’ or ‘entirety).

May 29, 2009 at 15:28
There is something about the “heritage” of our faith that has definitely been lost or “forgotten” (in the circles we came from) and I think even the start of finding answers to that does something inexplicable to a person’s soul… But that is me romanticizing the discovery not relaying anything facual… because I’ve been caught up in the desire to find where much of this “came from” for the past few years as well.
The things you have done in the last few years are completely fascinating… thank you for sharing some of it in these posts. I’m really excited for the rest of them.
May 29, 2009 at 15:56
No mention of incense? Or are we awaiting more Eastern postage?
May 29, 2009 at 16:07
Good thoughts, Reed! I look forward to your future (and further) ruminations.
May 30, 2009 at 13:33
I’ll admit, the old traditions are appealing to me simply because they are old. It’s always troubling when a newer church or denomination says they’ve got it right, as if up until this point everyone else has been close. That seems to make God or Jesus out to be insufficient at establishing a church, and it took a church or denomination split to get it right, finally.
While I don’t understand the roots and the formation of a lot of the traditions and rites and practices, it’s something I’ve been considering learning more about.
May 30, 2009 at 21:50
Reed,
Question – did you pick up on posture as it relates to worship in your travels?
May 31, 2009 at 15:22
Quickbeam: Do you mean physical posture? (sitting, standing, kneeling, etc…)
If yes, then yes.
To be honest, I enjoyed standing at the Orthodox church in Ukraine where there were no pews. I imagine it would be hard to maintain the proverbial “unofficial seating assignments” in such a church. I bet you would find yourself standing next to all sorts of people.
July 31, 2009 at 23:14
[...] Disconnect From Church History! I’ve discussed this elsewhere. Old stuff matters and Evangelicals seemed determined to separate themselves from [...]